In my view both extremes are in error. Let me explain.
Believers should rightly denounce behaviors such as barking like dogs, roaring like lions, laughing hysterically to the extent of falling out of chairs and rolling on the floor. These so-called manifestations of the spirit are all unbiblical and are demonically inspired behavior. Nowhere in the New Testament do we see this kind of activity described or prescribed for the church. The one instance of a man rolling around on the ground in an uncontrollable manner was due to demon possession.
On the other hand all denunciations of the work of the Holy Spirit in manifestations of the gifts of the Holy Spirit are equally in error. Many believers given to a reformed view of theology act as if the Holy Spirit packed up shop and left after Pentecost.
The Bible clearly teaches that the Holy Spirit is presently active in the lives of all believers; More so in those who acknowledge the work and ministry of the Holy Spirit. The book of Acts is a long testimony to what God will do through His spirit-filled people.
Consider for example that Jesus stated in Acts 1 that His followers would receive power from the Holy Spirit. There is no expiration date on the Holy Spirit’s working in the life of a believer. We see this demonstrated three chapters later. In Acts 4 Peter and John are brought before the Jewish religious leaders who are puzzled by the success of these simple followers of Christ, who are winning the hearts and minds of the people of Jerusalem. At issue in this latest incident was the healing of a lame man in the name of Jesus.
What puzzled the Jewish religious leaders the most? Was it the lack of correct theological training in the rabbinical schools of the day? I am sure that did cause some concern; but what really bothered the religious leaders was their unfamiliarity with the power behind the disciple’s acts. Note Acts 4:7 where they ask: “By what power, or in what name, have you done this?” referring to the healing of the lame man. Luke records Peter’s response as having been provided by the Holy Spirit in verse 8.
The Apostle Paul speaks of the present work of the Holy Spirit in believer’s lives when he says in Romans 8:11 that the same Holy Spirit that raised Jesus from the dead lives in us. Furthermore, Paul instructed the Galatians to remember that their spiritual life in Christ was begin by the power of the Holy Spirit and continues by that same power, not our fleshly efforts.
This same warning is applicable for believers today. We must be careful not to attribute works to the Holy Spirit that have no basis in Scripture. Likewise, believers must be open to the moving of the Holy Spirit in their lives in the same manner as demonstrated in the New Testament. There are many gifts God desires to give to His people for the building up of the body but alas, theological systems have become straight-jackets for some.
You may contact Pastor Mike at firstname.lastname@example.org